12 Comments

Great piece. It is an important move to contextualize the rise of AI inside the large flows of capitalism. I have been in reevaluation mode regarding AI these days. Here is a recent piece that summarizes some of my more practical insights. I feel like they are congruent to some extent with yours, Sam: https://open.substack.com/pub/nickpotkalitsky/p/the-art-of-imperfection-why-human?r=2l25hp&utm_medium=ios

Expand full comment

Reading outloud those Zarakol quotes, they make Tammerlane and Theodossius et al seem more tinkerers and artists and actors in a play than say: the Tammerlane in Calvino's Invisible Cities...The Davids' Dawn of Everything book succeeds also at giving us a reboot, I read 20 pages of that book for the purpose. Before his ongoing hysterics Morris Berman was on the verge of experiencing governance in a Give unto Caesar kind of way, his approx'ly last sane words were " despise your own devotions' . Sounds/feels true that the most what we would have called sovereign commune now will wear their hybrid incomes with stoic acceptance, myself could walk into an Amish community and likely win a spot as a hanger on, but it would be only a game because in my scheme of affections they should want me to bring another aggravated soul , and in this stageplay I am sketching, two goyim in this fashion would be asking for trouble. I mean in the 20th cent we would have ised the word svrgnty, and that seems metaphysical and a rigid word for a brittle combative stance now. Dumb down our Devotions, Dears?

Expand full comment

This is a minor quibble, but regarding “translation,” professional services firms have been using a version of AI (CAT tools: computer-assisted translation) for nigh on twenty years now. The “AI revolution” I think has been happening more slowly and consistently than most people think, and this discourse around AI is positing a sharp demarcation that I don’t think really exists.

Expand full comment

I love these Curations.

I found the theories of "The perplexing Varoufakis" to be provocative. As an amateur historian, I think the transition from feudalism to capitalism was very complex and took a very long time. It was also uneven, which is why it would have been confounding to Marx that the first revolution using marxist "talking points" was in relatively backwards Russia instead of Germany.

AI is probably inevitable as a productivity enhancement, but I think increased regulation of the tech companies and increased corporate taxes is also inevitable. I think there will be a reaction against peak profit margin capitalism somewhere between the New Deal and Progressivism.

Expand full comment